Special Covid-19 refund policy: We'll refund you in full if you can't travel due to Covid-19 governmental changes in travel restrictions. Details here.

Top 5 vacation rentals near Coney Island, New York

Searching for the perfect accommodation? Take a look at these gems and book your dream stay


Coney Island, Brooklyn NY

When visiting Brooklyn, NY, Coney Island has to be high on your list of things to see. It's renowned for a reason, so be sure to go and see what all the fuss is about. It isn't every day you find yourself so close to something so special.

Where to stay near Coney Island, Brooklyn, NY

Here is our pick of the top 5 vacation rentals. Make your choice and treat yourself to a luxury stay.

The Park Periphery

The Park Periphery, Plum Guide home in New York

The Park Periphery, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book The Park Periphery now: from £194 per night With the 25-acre Battery Park at your feet and a rooftop pool above, dive right into the dynamic lifestyle of the city's Financial District. You'll find this bright studio in a glossy apartment block among art deco buildings. Its sleek and simple decor features some subtle bursts of colour – an interior that seems to echo the vibe of the surrounding area. Stroll through streets full of modern high-rises on your way to pick up Australian-style coffee, Xi'an noodles, or market-fresh groceries. Despite what you'd expect from studio living, there is a fully equipped kitchen and plenty of room to make yourself at home. Power through your nine-to-five in the plush co-working space, then relax in the shared lounge as the sun sets over Manhattan. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom


Soprano, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Soprano, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Click to book Soprano now: from £118 per night We’ll give you the great news right off the bat – at Soprano guests can use the building’s private fitness centre, as well as the rooftop terrace, which has plenty of seating and great views. But that’s not all we love here. The interior of the home is beautifully curated, and the contrast of a dark blue wall next to a bright yellow chair is both energising and serene at the same time. Of course, it is only a studio, but with so many great attractions on your doorstep (or at least easily accessible via the subway), there's no need for a tonne of space. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

Champagne Visions

Champagne Visions, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Champagne Visions, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Click to book Champagne Visions now: from £250 per night This picture-perfect studio is on the smaller side, but with its whimsical design, we’re struggling to find any faults. The Edison lightbulbs, subway tiling, and bronze fixtures also make this home a perfect representation of its location – a trendy and historical part of Brooklyn, this is uber cool Williamsburg. Your nearest subway station can get you to Lower Manhattan in just five minutes and the area surrounding the station is vibrant with bars, restaurants, and cafes. Whether you choose to take a bite out of Manhattan or Brooklyn, you'll thank us later for Champagne Visions. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

Harbour Master

Harbour Master, Plum Guide home in NYC

Harbour Master, Plum Guide home in NYC

Click to book Harbour Master now: from £231 per night At the very southernmost tip of Manhattan Island, by the picturesque, tree-lined Battery Park, this elegant studio apartment is the perfect sanctuary away from home in the heart of the Big Apple. Overlooking the open water of New York Harbour, you’ll be perfectly placed to explore everything Lower Manhattan has to offer, from the narrow, historic streets around the financial district, to the vibrant restaurants and bars of Soho. Inside the apartment, the tasteful interiors give the whole space a sense of character and charm, while the furniture always strikes a balance between form and function, being both comfortable and stylish. Prepare a delicious New York-inspired meal and sit down to eat at the cosy little dining table. Then, choose to either indulge in a long soak in the bathtub or opt for a quick shower to freshen up before heading out into the bright lights of the city. During a night in, kick off your shoes and put your feet up on the sofa, ready for a night of relaxation in front of a movie. If you want to truly experience New York City, then base yourself in the heart of the action in this gorgeous studio home. Sleeps up to 2 | 0 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

Piu Mosso

Piu Mosso, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Piu Mosso, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Click to book Piu Mosso now: from £104 per night Enjoy the building’s private gym and stunning rooftop terrace, with views that stretch across Manhattan and Brooklyn. At Piu Mosso no detail is overlooked, and even though it is only a studio apartment, it’s charming and super convenient. There is plenty of storage space for guests to unpack their bags and the location is also great for business or pleasure. While this area is mainly commercial, there are some real gems. Stone Street, for example, is definitely worth checking out – a charming, cobbled street lined with culinary delights from all around the world. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

Plum Guide journal banner

Why book through Plum Guide?

  • We review every single home available in each of our destinations, and select only the top 3%.
  • Our Home Critics review thousands of homes and put the best to the test, obsessing over every last detail.
  • Our expert team is just a phone call away and always ready to help you.

Read what our guests have to say on Trustpilot.

Other popular places around Coney Island, Brooklyn, NY

Stay in the world's most beautiful homes

Search for a holiday home