Special Covid-19 refund policy: We'll refund you in full if you can't travel due to Covid-19 governmental changes in travel restrictions. Details here.

Top 5 vacation rentals near Little Italy, New York

Searching for the perfect accommodation? Take a look at these gems and book your dream stay


Little Italy, Manhattan, New York

When visiting New York, Little Italy has to be high on your list of things to see. It's renowned for a reason, so be sure to go and see what all the fuss is about. It isn't every day you find yourself so close to something so special.

Where to stay near Little Italy, New York

Here is our pick of the top 5 vacation rentals. Make your choice and treat yourself to a luxury stay.

Beaming With Delight

Beaming With Delight, Plum Guide home in New York

Beaming With Delight, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book Beaming With Delight now: from £173 per night What was once a cork factory has since been renovated to reveal its beautiful & unique characteristics in industrial-style loft apartments. Situated in Greenpoint Brooklyn, it'd only make sense to highlight the stripped wooden beams and brick walls in this loft. The kitchen doesn't get a ton of natural light, but we're being nit-picky here. It's otherwise a nice choice outside the hustle and bustle of the city. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

Checkerboard Dreams

Checkerboard Dreams, Plum Guide home in New York

Checkerboard Dreams, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book Checkerboard Dreams now: from £13.64 per night With its characterful vintage townhouses, proximity to cultural hotspots such as the New York Public Library, and an overall slower pace of life, it's easy to see why Murray Hill is fast becoming a magnet for edgy graduates, trendy young professionals, and families. And you'll immediately want to join them once you've stayed at this rare Manhattan gem perched near the East River and just an eight-minute walk from Grand Central station. Design-wise, it's certainly pleasing to the eye. Crisp white walls are punctuated with cheerful splashes of burnt orange and a beautiful wooden chequerboard floor throughout creates a nice zen-like flow between the rooms. But the highlight for us isn't the chic interior, nor even the private balcony with scenic river views, it's the building's gorgeous glass-panelled swimming pool with its intricately mosaicked floor. On the rare days you don't make it to the pool (or the on-site gym), there's more than enough space for living room yoga on that stylish, striped rug. If you fancy upping the relaxation, there's nowhere better than the sun-drenched roof deck with its comfortable seating areas and stunning views of the Empire State Building. However, there's a large communal lounge too should the weather take a turn. Sleeps up to 4 | 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Piu Mosso

Piu Mosso, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Piu Mosso, Plum Guide home in Brooklyn NY

Click to book Piu Mosso now: from £104 per night Enjoy the building’s private gym and stunning rooftop terrace, with views that stretch across Manhattan and Brooklyn. At Piu Mosso no detail is overlooked, and even though it is only a studio apartment, it’s charming and super convenient. There is plenty of storage space for guests to unpack their bags and the location is also great for business or pleasure. While this area is mainly commercial, there are some real gems. Stone Street, for example, is definitely worth checking out – a charming, cobbled street lined with culinary delights from all around the world. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

White Paint Splash

White Paint Splash, Plum Guide home in New York

White Paint Splash, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book White Paint Splash now: from £282 per night Effortlessly chic, modern, and accompanied by skyscraper views over the city – this home really belongs in New York. Located in the bustling hubbub of commerce and cultural attractions, find yourself in Midtown – the beating heart of Manhattan. Take in your surroundings on top of the Empire State Building (fifteen minutes on foot), stop off for a pretzel or bagel on your way to Central Park, just a thirty-minute stroll, and make sure to take the twenty-minute walk to Times Square for the quintessential NYC experience of neon-lit billboards, vibrant bars, and authentic American diners. Back home, the light-filled living space benefits from an open-plan concept that creates a sociable and seamless area to unwind. Mixing soft thoughtful furnishings with vintage rugs, leather chairs, a hand-crafted coffee table and sleek wooden flooring makes for a relaxing and appealing space to kick back with a good book, map out your day of sightseeing, or look through new purchases. Elsewhere in the building, you'll be able to keep up your morning workout routine at the gym and bookmark the day with sundown drinks on the communal rooftop terrace, offering skyline vistas of the Big Apple. Sleeps up to 2 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom

Plum Guide journal banner

Why book through Plum Guide?

  • We review every single home available in each of our destinations, and select only the top 3%.
  • Our Home Critics review thousands of homes and put the best to the test, obsessing over every last detail.
  • Our expert team is just a phone call away and always ready to help you.

Read what our guests have to say on Trustpilot.

Other popular places around Little Italy, New York

Stay in the world's most beautiful homes

Search for a holiday home