Special Covid-19 refund policy: We'll refund you in full if you can't travel due to Covid-19 governmental changes in travel restrictions. Details here.

Top 5 vacation rentals near The Hall of Fame for Great Americans, NY

Searching for the perfect accommodation? Take a look at these gems and book your dream stay


Abraham Lincoln on a dollar bill

When visiting New York, The Hall of Fame for Great Americans has to be high on your list of things to see. It's renowned for a reason, so be sure to go and see what all the fuss is about. It isn't every day you find yourself so close to something so special.

Where to stay near The Hall of Fame for Great Americans, New York

Here is our pick of the top 5 vacation rentals. Make your choice and treat yourself to a luxury stay.

Pear Tree Gables

Pear Tree Gables, Plum Guide home in New York

Pear Tree Gables, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book Pear Tree Gables now: from £600 per night Situated on a private cobblestone street full of vintage Victorian row houses, this home feels like it’s out of an old picture book of New York. And with the historic Morris-Jumel Mansion and its beautiful gardens at the end of the block, (George Washington stayed in this now-museum during the Revolutionary War), a slice of history is forever embedded into this charming street. Inside the home though, you’ll find the 1882 Victorian facade falls away to a simple but highly stylized interior – exposed brick fireplaces, wooden beams, floating staircases, antique pine floors and leather furniture – this gorgeous home was featured in Dwell magazine for good reason. Upstairs, the master bedroom is wonderfully bright from skylights. We particularly love the ground floor garden, with its weathered brick walls and large luminous pear tree – it offers a private spot of fresh air to catch your breath in this busy city. Once you’ve adequately recharged, it’s time to set out – the bustle of Harlem offers world-famous soul food, jazz clubs and gospel churches. Just at the end of the block, you’ll find the 163rd St subway station, which can whisk you away to all corners of the city for even more exploration. Sleeps up to 6 | 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Hideaway Parlor

Hideaway Parlor, Plum Guide home in New York

Hideaway Parlor, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book Hideaway Parlor now: from £97 per night Originally built in the 1800's, this Harlem apartment has been beautifully preserved, showcasing its original tiled fireplace, vintage lighting fixtures, and claw foot tub. The host has creatively elevated this vintage vibe with an antique dentist's chair and Tin Tin statuettes. Your immediate neighbourhood is tree lined and quiet and a bit of a ways from the city's epicentre - but it's a true delight should you want a peaceful retreat in NYC. Sleeps up to 4 | 1 Bedroom | 1 Bathroom


Wonderland, Plum Guide home in New York

Wonderland, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book Wonderland now: from £900 per night Prepare to be amazed in this truly extraordinary home. To call it 'one of a kind' doesn't do it justice - it is packed FULL with extraordinary things that its owner has picked up from all over the world. This enormous house is in fact a converted church and has been lovingly crafted into a much-loved home over the years. Minimalists or guests who are fussy about general wear and tear should look elsewhere, but for most people, this will be pure heaven! Undoubtedly one of the most unique homes we have on our books. Sleeps up to 9 | 5 Bedrooms | 4 Bathrooms

Harlem Parisian

Harlem Parisian, Plum Guide home in New York

Harlem Parisian, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book Harlem Parisian now: from £500 per night It will come as no surprise that your host is Parisian – the interiors here have a distinctively French feel. This sophisticated and classical restraint is paired boldly with bright graffiti artwork, a look that is just as diverse as its location. The apartment (up eighty-two steps in a building with no lift) sits at the top of a beautiful, century-old brownstone in the ever-vibrant neighbourhood of Harlem. This part of Manhattan has become hugely popular in recent years, owing to its rich history, diverse culture, outstanding food, and energetic nightlife. Sleeps up to 6 | 3 Bedrooms | 1 Bathroom

The Presidential

The Presidential, Plum Guide home in New York

The Presidential, Plum Guide home in New York

Click to book The Presidential now: from £2499 per night Perfect for celebratory occasions, this UES townhouse is a luxury home base for your family reunion, wedding reception, or birthday extravaganza. This home is a certified event space and boasts a personal concierge service plus an impressive list of contacts for all of your hosting necessities. And with over 6000 square feet of both indoor and outdoor space, you can truly elevate all of your entertainment dreams. So, now that you've got the home, the only thing left to do is plan the party of the year. Sleeps up to 16 | 7 Bedrooms | 7 Bathrooms

Plum Guide journal banner

Why book through Plum Guide?

  • We review every single home available in each of our destinations, and select only the top 3%.
  • Our Home Critics review thousands of homes and put the best to the test, obsessing over every last detail.
  • Our expert team is just a phone call away and always ready to help you.

Read what our guests have to say on Trustpilot.

Other popular places around The Hall of Fame for Great Americans, New York

Stay in the world's most beautiful homes

Search for a holiday home