Become a host
  • 6 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

  • 3 bathrooms

Add dates for price

Ask the host anything

Do you have a question about this home or the local area?

This home on historic Shelter Island is as vibrant as they come. Designed by noted NYC architects Paul Aferiat and Peter Stamberg – and featured in many a magazine and television show – the home blends the line between art and architecture in a glorious exploration of Newtonian colour theory. The colour is bold – from a lime green roof, to shocking pink and orange walls, to a canary yellow dining table – and translucent walls make the whole space glow. There’s a hanging, rotating fireplace to keep you cosy, a private swimming pool to cool off in, and a Bertazzoni range cooker to keep the culinary whizz of your group happy. The house is split into two parts, giving a balance of privacy and places to gather. And it’s likely that you’ll be gathering outside by the pool to grill a feast as you relax in the sunshine. When you head out, you’ll find the small private beach at Coecles Harbor a short walk away, and a five-minute drive will take you to the many larger beaches in the area.


The Plum Promise

  • No time for average – We reject thousands of homes worldwide, so you don't have to.
  • Hosts we know – With track records of high-quality hosting.
  • Rated ‘Excellent’ on Trustpilot – Exceptional service before, during and after your stay.

Ask the host anything

Do you have a question about this home or the local area?

What to expect


Highlights

Walk to the private beach at Coecles Harbor, just moments away

Walk to the private beach at Coecles Harbor, just moments away

Admire the space designed by renowned architects

Admire the space designed by renowned architects

Enjoy the vibrant colours throughout

Enjoy the vibrant colours throughout

Start your day with a few laps in the pool

Start your day with a few laps in the pool

Like what you see? Explore more of this home

Home truths

    The home is arranged in two parts – one contains the living/dining room, kitchen, master bedroom and bathroom while the other has two bedrooms, two bathrooms and a convertible TV room

    There are beds available for eight guests, but the maximum occupancy of the home is six guests

    The pool is heated and will typically only be available between Memorial Day and Labor Day due to the climate in the northeaster US – if you're booking outside of this period and would like to use the pool, please ask the host whether it will be available

    Unfortunately, pets are not allowed in this home

About this stay


Amenities

Home cinema setup

Wi-fi

Air conditioning

Pets allowed

Parking available

Washing machine

Bedrooms & bathrooms

4 bedrooms, 6 beds

3 bathrooms

Extras


Additional fees

  • There may be some extra fees to pay here, such as charges for utilities, final cleaning fees, city tax and security deposits – all of which you may need to pay in cash to the homeowner. Please reach out during the booking process to confirm.

Additional fees subject to a 3.5% handling charge.

Extras are subject to availability. Please enquire with your host.

Local guide


About Shelter Island

Reachable only by ferries, private boats, or small seaplanes, getting to Shelter Island is something of an adventure. And once you’re there, its turn-of-the-century charm, historical buildings, relaxed attitude and endless nature preserves (that make up one-third of the island) captivate city escapees and year-round residents alike. This bucolic island has quaint restaurants that feel more like home kitchens, farmer’s markets at the island’s historical society and silky stretches of...

Explore the area

Local restaurants, cafes, museums, sites and activities, recommended by our community of hosts and travel experts

Explore the Rich Political History of Shelter Island

Explore the Rich Political History of Shelter Island

Immerse yourself in the fascinating political history of Shelter Island, a locality known for its significant role in shaping the region's governance. Discover historical landmarks and gain a deeper understanding of the area's past.

Stay at Shelter Island House

Stay at Shelter Island House

Quaint country inn with casual-chic rooms, outdoor lounge, bakery, pool, and friendly staff. Enjoy private beaches, biking, and good food nearby. A lovely weekend getaway.

Paddle through Shelter Island with Venture Out

Paddle through Shelter Island with Venture Out

Venture Out Paddle Board Rentals offers an unforgettable experience exploring Shelter Island's waters. With knowledgeable guides, top-notch equipment, and excellent service, it's the perfect way to stay active and have fun on your holiday.

Savour Fresh Oysters at Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market

Savour Fresh Oysters at Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market

Shucked oysters & local beers served in a snug harborside cottage with a market & outdoor seating. Great atmosphere, delicious drinks, and an A+ waterfront location.

Shop at The Weathered Barn

Shop at The Weathered Barn

Discover a genuinely lovely store in the North Fork that offers unique, high-quality items at fair prices. From diffusers and candles to soaps and cookware, this is the go-to shop for gifts and personal indulgences.

Explore Mitchell Park & Marina

Explore Mitchell Park & Marina

A perfect beach for families with little kids, featuring a delightful carousel ride and a picturesque boardwalk. Enjoy the vibrant atmosphere with concerts and dancing, or simply take a leisurely walk around the beautiful marina.

Dine at Noah's

Dine at Noah's

Experience the best of New American cuisine with a focus on local ingredients at this modern restaurant and bar. Indulge in incredible seafood dishes, from lobster rolls to tuna poké bowls, and enjoy generous portions and stellar service.

Savour the Scenic Views at Kontokosta Winery

Savour the Scenic Views at Kontokosta Winery

Indulge in a delightful experience at Kontokosta Winery, offering breathtaking views of the sound. Sip on exquisite wines and relish delectable snacks amidst the stunning surroundings of this charming establishment.

Explore the Serene Ruth Oliva Preserve

Explore the Serene Ruth Oliva Preserve

Take a leisurely stroll along the red trail and be treated to stunning views of waterfront and woodlands. Spot deer, ospreys, and even eagles with fish in their talons.

Explore 67 Steps Beach

Explore 67 Steps Beach

A cute little rocky beach with beautiful views and clear waters. Accessible only by wooden stairs, it offers an intimate and quiet place to enjoy the ocean on Long Island.

Explore the historic premises of 8 W Water St

Explore the historic premises of 8 W Water St

Step back in time as you explore the fascinating history of 8 W Water St. Immerse yourself in the stories and architecture of this iconic location.

Dine at Tutto il Giorno Sag

Dine at Tutto il Giorno Sag

Experience the incredible flavors of Italian cuisine at this year-round restaurant. Enjoy a romantic and homey ambiance, friendly staff, and flavorful dishes like the Risotto and Tortelli.

Booking policies


House Rules

Children welcome (1-12 years)

Infants welcome (under 12 months)

Pets welcome

No smoking

No parties or events

Good to know

Arrival from 15:00

Departure before 11:00

Air con

Wifi

Cancellation policy

  • Up until

    60

    days

    Cancel at least 60 days before your check-in date for a 50% refund.

  • Not eligible for a refund once your check-in date is under 60 days away.

Host


This home is managed by Bryan

This home is managed directly by a business. A member of their staff will be your point of contact before and during your stay. Bryan and his team are vacation experts, especially when it comes to The Hamptons and surrounding towns. With years of experience, they’re with you every step of the vacation rental process – and they take pride in giving their guests a personalised experience to remember.

Property classified as: common.undefined.propertyTypes.non-hotel.name

This home is a Plum Guide Award winner.

  • Great hosts, not just great homes – We reject homes managed by hosts who don’t meet our standards of excellence.

The Plum Promise

  • Every home scrutinised by experts, they have to meet our standards.
  • Hosts we knowHigh-quality hosting, with track records of high-quality hosting.
  • Impeccably clean, well maintained homes.
  • Peace of mind in the rare event your host cancels.
  • Rated ‘Excellent’ on Trustpilot, delivering exceptional service before, during and after your stay.