Rent Luxury Cottages in Montauk

The best and most popular Cottages in Montauk

• Star of the Show
• Ocean Wave
• Friends of Friends
• Saltbush
• Long Story Short

With Plum Guide, you can choose from 18 luxury Cottages in Montauk. Find your ideal home with help from our friendly team of experts, and you're sure to have a trip to remember. Filter your search based on features such as specific amenities, number of guests, price per night and much more.

To amend a booking, or cancel it completely, please complete this form and wait for one of our friendly experts to get back to you. We will endeavour to respond to your query within 24 hours. Please note that, until you receive official confirmation, no changes will have been made to your booking for one of the luxury holiday Cottages in our Montauk collection.

All of the luxury Montauk Cottages available to book on our site have been meticulously tested to ensure quality you can trust. Through our expert-led approach to vetting the quality of a home – considering everything from the shower pressure to the artwork on the walls – we have acquired industry-leading customer satisfaction scores that speak for themselves.