The Best Homes in Shelter Island.
Award-winning homes from £98
Home spotlights in Shelter Island
We've selected the top 3% homes in Shelter Island.
Explore the 896 most perfect homes in our collection
Most popular homes in Shelter Island.
Check rates and availability for Shelter Island.
Book with Plum Guide.
ONLY THE BEST
HOMES.
Our team of local experts vet every home, only accepting the top 3% to guarantee an exceptional stay every time.
AWARD-WINNING
CARE.
Efficient and empowered home and travel experts, whose sole task is to make your stay exceptional.
UNRIVALLED
PROTECTION.
In the rare event your host cancels, we’ll aim to find you a new Plum Guide home up to 20% more expensive than the original. Within 5 days of check-in, it’s up to 50%.
Frequently Asked Questions
About this location
Searching for your dream home in Shelter Island? You've come to the right place: we’re the official selection of the world’s best homes. Our collection of homes in Shelter Island come fully furnished with well-equipped kitchens, toiletries in bathrooms & all linen included. We obsessively check each home for you, so you can book a short or extended stay with peace of mind.
Search Our CollectionAbout this location
Searching for your dream home in Shelter Island? You've come to the right place: we’re the official selection of the world’s best homes. Our collection of homes in Shelter Island come fully furnished with well-equipped kitchens, toiletries in bathrooms & all linen included. We obsessively check each home for you, so you can book a short or extended stay with peace of mind.
Search Our Collection
Similar destinations
Similar destinations