The Pond House
5 guests
3 bedrooms
Woodstock, Ulster County
This Woodstock residence is one for the design-savvy folk. Once a studio belonging to acclaimed realist painter Reginald Marsh, the space has been transformed into a stunning family home.
Shelter Island Homes for Four People
We selected the 528 homes worth renting in this location
Home spotlights in Shelter Island
On the Edge of Nature
4 guests
3 bedrooms
Gardiner, New York
It’s the end of the line. Beyond this chalet, there’s nothing but Minnewaska’s protected preserveland.
A Country Call
4 guests
2 bedrooms
Bellport, Brookhaven
This sunny 1920s home lies in the heart of Bellport Village. While you'll be close to a few lovely shops and restaurants, we think you'll want a car here for getting to see the best of Long Island, not to mention the range of nearby beaches including Mother's Beach and Shirley Beach.
Art & Nature
6 guests
4 bedrooms
Cragsmoor, Wawarsing
This home's architecture, interiors and colourful prints all share a mid-century modern style, but its woodland surroundings are more Hansel and Gretel than Gilbert and George. In a tiny hamlet in upstate New York, it’s surrounded by mountains, lakes and forest – great for skiers, hikers and wild swimmers alike.
We selected the top 3% holiday homes in Shelter Island Homes for Four People
Explore the 528 most perfect homes in our collection
View on map
Check upcoming rates & availability for Shelter Island Homes for Four People
Frequently asked questions
Similar destinations
Explore our collection of homes for 4 people in Shelter Island. Plum Guide’s homes come fully furnished with the best-equipped kitchens, essential bathroom toiletries and all linen included. Book today and enjoy a short or extended stay in the best 4 person homes that Shelter Island has to offer. Our friendly team of Plum Experts are on-hand 24/7 should you need anything.
Search Our Collection