Long Story Short
4 guests
2 bedrooms
Montauk, East Hampton
For the ultimate Montauk escape with style and character in abundance, this fisherman's cottage has you covered. Flamingo-pink shutters and the front door set the scene for a stay that's thoughtfully stylish, charming and quirky – a blend of boho and rustic that's sophisticated and easy to love.
Art & Nature
6 guests
4 bedrooms
Cragsmoor, Wawarsing
This home's architecture, interiors and colourful prints all share a mid-century modern style, but its woodland surroundings are more Hansel and Gretel than Gilbert and George. In a tiny hamlet in upstate New York, it’s surrounded by mountains, lakes and forest – great for skiers, hikers and wild swimmers alike.
Explore the 250 most perfect homes in our collection
All Plum Guide houses in Shelter Island have been tested and approved by our team of independent home critics. These meticulous beings inspect everything –from the convenience of each house’s location right down to the art on the walls– so what you see really is what you get. Worried about thin curtains? Accessibility? Maybe wifi speed is your biggest concern? Rest assured, we obsessively check each house in Shelter Island before approving it, so you can book with peace of mind.
