Book Luxury Airbnb Alternatives in Shelter Island

The best and most popular Airbnb Alternatives in Shelter Island

• Ahoy There
• Port & Starboard
• Grand Optimist
• Villa Menantic

There are currently best luxury Airbnb Alternatives in our Shelter Island collection, all of which are available to book. Should you need any help in choosing the right one for you, our team of experts is on hand to offer any assistance. Filter your search based on features such as price per night, number of beds, number of guests and more to ensure you find the perfect home.

To make any changes to your booking for one of the luxury Airbnb Alternatives in our Shelter Island collection, including cancellation, please fill out this form and wait for a reply from our friendly team. We will strive to provide a response as soon as possible, but until you are officially notified, we will not have dealt with your request.

At Plum Guide, customer satisfaction is our number one priority. We don't list a lot of homes, just the right ones. Every home in our collection is put through a meticulous vetting process, with only the top 3% going on to become Plum Award winners. So when you book one of our luxury Shelter Island Airbnb Alternatives, you can rest assured that your stay will be up to the high standard you deserve.