Book Luxury Airbnb Alternatives in Shelter Island

We selected the 914 homes worth renting in this location

Who's coming along?

Adults

Age 13+

0

Children

Age 1 to 12

0

Infants

Under 1

0

Pets

An extra fee may apply

0

Home spotlights in Shelter Island

Kennedies

Kennedies

  • 9 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

North Sea, Southampton

An idyllic escape for all the family, this waterfront home sits in the hamlet of North Sea, part of larger Southhampton, and within an easy drive of a wide selection of restaurants, boutique shops and beautiful beaches. Whether you're here for a weekend or a longer stay, you'll immediately feel relaxed in this quiet spot, surrounded by nature.

Long Story Short

Long Story Short

  • 4 guests

  • 2 bedrooms

Montauk, East Hampton

For the ultimate Montauk escape with style and character in abundance, this fisherman's cottage has you covered. Flamingo-pink shutters and the front door set the scene for a stay that's thoughtfully stylish, charming and quirky – a blend of boho and rustic that's sophisticated and easy to love.

Divine Inspiration

Divine Inspiration

  • 10 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

Great Barrington, Lee

There are a lot of adjectives we could throw at this home in The Berkshires; cosy, darling, divine. But none of them really do it justice.

Straight Down the Middle

Straight Down the Middle

  • 8 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island

Escape the frenetic pace of daily life and revel in an unmissable opportunity to relax and recharge at this stunning Shelter Island getaway. Set on a quiet tree-lined street and just a ten-minute walk from the pebble-strewn seashore, the home is perfectly set up for family holidays and weekend retreats with friends.


We selected the top 3% holiday homes in Shelter Island Airbnb Alternatives

Explore the 914 most perfect homes in our collection

View on map

Most popular homes in Shelter Island

Wander Inn

Wander Inn

  • 6 guests

  • 2 bedrooms

Southold, New York

Long Island Iced Tea

Long Island Iced Tea

  • 8 guests

  • 3 bedrooms

Remsenburg, Remsenburg-Speonk

Technicolour Dreamland

Technicolour Dreamland

  • 6 guests

  • 3 bedrooms

Northwest Harbor, East Hampton

Hampton Set

Hampton Set

  • 6 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

Northwest Harbor, East Hampton

The Captain's House

The Captain's House

  • 10 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

Jamesport, North Fork

Summer Fridays

Summer Fridays

  • 10 guests

  • 5 bedrooms

Northwest Harbor, East Hampton

Long Point

Long Point

  • 8 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

Noyack, Southampton

Crop And Saddle

Crop And Saddle

  • 6 guests

  • 4 bedrooms

Washington, Litchfield

View all

Check upcoming rates & availability for Shelter Island Airbnb Alternatives


Frequently asked questions

Airbnb is a shot in the dark. We meticulously vet all our homes in Shelter Island to ensure you won’t waste your precious holiday. Every home you'll find on Plum Guide comes fully furnished with the best-equipped kitchens, essential bathroom toiletries and all linen included. Before being accepted into our collection, each home much pass a meticulous vetting process, culminating in a personal home visit from an independent Home Critic. Rent one of Plum Guide's luxury Shelter Island Airbnb Alternatives, and enjoy a long or short stay to remember. Should you need any assistance with your booking, our friendly team of experts will be on hand to guide you through the process.

Search our collection