There's no better place to book luxury Holiday Apartments in Shelter Island, NY, U.S. than our exclusive Plum Guide collection, which includes only the top 3% of homes. Every one of the homes on our site has been put through a painstaking vetting process with 150 checkpoints, culminating in a visit from a professional Home Critic. Every one of the remarkable homes on our books come fully furnished, with all linen and essential bathroom toiletries included, as well as a perfectly-equipped kitchen. Choose from one of the best Apartments for Rent in our Shelter Island range, and discover the true meaning of luxury. Call on the help of our dedicated team too, to help make your choice as straightforward as possible.