Shelter Island Coastal Homes

The best and most popular Coastal Homes in Shelter Island

• Ahoy There
• Villa Menantic
• Grand Optimist
• Port & Starboard

There are best results in our range of available Coastal Homes that you can book in Shelter Island. You can narrow down your search based on price, number of guests, amenities, bed sizes and more. If you need assistance to book your dream stay, our friendly Plum Experts are on-hand 24/7 to help you find the perfect Coastal Homes for your trip to Shelter Island.

To cancel or change your booking, you must fill out this form and wait for a response from our team. We will endeavour to get back to you within 24 hours.

We put every home through a meticulous 150-point test, and accept only the top 3%. With customer satisfaction our number one priority, you know that a stay with us is a stay of guaranteed quality.