Rent Luxury Cottages in Shelter Island

We selected the best homes worth renting in this location

Check upcoming rates & availability for Shelter Island Cottages

Discover our curated collection of luxury holiday Cottages in Shelter Island, NY, U.S.. We painstakingly review all homes available in a destination and accept only the top 3% to ensure quality our guests can trust. Each of the Shelter Island Cottages in our collection comes fully furnished with essential bathroom toiletries, expertly-equipped kitchens and all linens included. Book your dream stay today and should you need some help, our friendly team of experts are on hand to help plan your perfect Cottage break.