Shelter Island

Home Critic Charlotte spills the secrets on how to spot a great host: from what to look for in the kitchen cupboards to the quality of the welcome pack. 

Notes from a Home Critic: The Secret Tells of a Great Host

Award-winning homes from [price]

[destination] [facetName]

luxury

Find a luxury home

outdoor-space

Find a home with outdoor space

car-parking

Find a home with a car parking space

Long Stay Rentals

Shelter Island, NY, U.S.

Our vetted long stay rentals in [address] promise gorgeous design, well-equipped kitchens, luxury bathroom toiletries and all linens included. At Plum Guide, we obsessively check each apartment for you, so you can book your extended stay in [address] with peace of mind.

Shelter Island Long Stay Rentals

Award-winning homes from £98